Fighting Isn't The Issue, Cheap Shots Are

NHL dean of discipline Colin Campbell tells CBN that the NHL "may examine fighting."  While Campbell says he's not against it, the door is opening for Gary Bettman to finally get his way and ban it from the sport. 

Recently, there have been a rash of injuries caused by rough play.  Outside of the Chris Simon incident, which had Simon going out of his way to whack an opponent with his stick, most of the injuries have been acquired incidentally:  Nashville Predator Jordin Tootoo defending himself from a charging Stephan Robadais of the Dallas Stars; Atlanta's Jon Sim out indefinitely a broken left orbital bone suffered in a fight Thursday with San Jose's Mark Bell and Todd Fedoruk of the Philadelphia Flyers knocked unconscious by a punch from Colton Orr of the New York Rangers.

In most cases, a hockey fight consists of two big guys coming together (Donald Bashir and George LaRoque come to mind) who clutch and grab, try to land a couple of punches and miss and are escorted off the ice to the adoring cheers of the crowd.  It is rare that anyone ever gets hurt or that the fight even gets mentioned the next day, unless it is the afore mentioned heavyweights and they land a few punches.  The crowd goes nuts, the teams get fired up and everybody moves on.  The days of guys like Dave Schultz and Tiger Williams are long past.

I agree that cheap shots like Simon's or Todd Bertuzzi's have no place in any civilized game.  When a players uses a stick to deliberately hack another player in the head or when a player cross checks from behind, I agree that he should have the book thrown at him.  But banning two big guys from swinging at each other with ungloved fists, nah, I like that.  And so do hockey fans.

Truthfully, most of the stars in the league don't fight.  In fact, they are protected by their teammates if someone goes after them.  That's why Robadais charged at Tootoo, because Tootoo was whipping up on Mike Modono.
Tootoo's only transgression was that he violated the sacred code by not removing his glove.  But honestly, when you look at that video, you get the fact he was just defending himself and there was no intent like in Simon's attack.

There are cheap shots in every sport.  When they happen the person or persons are fined for their actions.  Baseball has the inside pitch, which is still a vital part of the game; football has the late hit and basketball has the flagrant foul.  In those sports, fighting is looked upon as barbaric and tempers just boil over until someone gets hurt.  In hockey, fighting is the like the valve on a pressure cooker, releasing the tension, getting out the aggression before things get way out of hand.

If the NHL were smart, they would crack down on intentional, unprovoked shots to the head that happen after the play.  They would have stiffer suspensions for cross checking from behind.  But they would not make this a totally European game by banning fighting.  After all, it's what the fans enjoy.

Lightning Round

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.