Let's Make Interleague Play Really Interesting


I used to think interleague play was a cool thing.  The White Sox and Cubs meeting each other six times a year was awesome and having the bragging rights over my Cub friends was a particular guilty pleasure.  I would watch the games, yell a lot and hang on every pitch like it was the world series.  In fact, I almost got booted from a bar in Nashville because I got a little too into the game.

But that all changed on October 26, 2005 when the Chicago White Sox won the big piece of hardware.  No matter how many times the Sox beat the Cubs, it is not like watching them beat the Astros in the world series.  Playing for a championship is far more compelling than playing for bragging rights.  Cub fans can brag all they want, it's still been 99 years since they took home the big trophy.

In thinking it through, interleague makes sense for the markets or states with two teams. Fans in Florida, Chicago, New York, LA, Oakland, Ohio and Missouri can enjoy some friendly rivalries. But some of the forced rivalries are silly.  You'd have to be my 83 year-old father, who grew up in Brookline, MA, to get why the Braves play the Red Sox.  Will the Rangers play the  Nationals every year  or the Orioles play the Cardinals?  How about Athletics-Phillies.  Or Twins-Nationals.  Or Mariners-Brewers? Consult you baseball history book if you can't keep up.

Most interleague matchups are underwhelming.  And the ones that excite the fans excite only the fans.  Ozzie Guillen or Lou Piniella are not going to manage any differently or any more urgently against the Cubs or Sox.  Ozzie is more concerned about the Indians, Tigers and Twins while Lou frets about the Astros, Brewers and Cardinals.  The players, who come from all over the world, have no sense of what this means to the average guy who is born and bred in a certain locale. 

The only fix that works is to realign everything and put the teams in the same city in the same division. Do what the NFL or NBA or NHL does and have all one league with two 15 team conferences in six divisions.

Eastern Conference

Northeast Division
Boston, Yankees, Mets, Toronto, Philadelphia
North Division
Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Detroit, Minnesota, Cincinnati
South Division
Atlanta, Tampa, Florida, Baltimore, Washington
Western Conference

Midwest Division
Cubs, White Sox, St. Louis, Kansas City, Milwaukee
Mountain Division
Colorado, Arizona, Houston, Texas, Seattle
West Division
Anaheim, Los Angeles, San Diego, Oakland, San Fransisco

Now, these games actually mean something. BTW, here's a brilliant piece from a site called "Bat Girl" which is actually a Twinkie site, but funny none the less.

Lightning Round

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.