If Ifs and Buts Were Candy & Nuts, We'd All Win Another World Series

I love how sports talk radio hosts can stir it up just by saying silly, outrageous things.  One of the best at this is Mike North, the morning show personality on WSCR in Chicago.

In lamenting the plight of the 2007 White Sox yesterday morning, North made it a point to demonstrate how, in his opinion, the Sox have unloaded an all-star team and if they had those parts back, they might still be winning.  Boy, is he off his meds.

Think about it.  If the Sox hadn't made the moves that they did, there would be no 2005 championship. For instance, trading Carlos Lee to the Brewers scored the White Sox both Scott Podsednik and
Luis Vizcaino, two huge parts of the 2005 championship team.  In fact, I would argue that without those two, there would be no 2005 championship.  And Carlos, to this day, has not played on a team with a winning record outside of Chicago.

The big one is always Mags Ordóñez.  But from Kenny's standpoint there were valid concerns.  Mags was coming off knee surgery in a contract year.  No one knew what would happen, and to be truthful, Ordóñez struggled in 2005, was solid in 2006 and is back to star status in 2007.  But because of the injury, Kenny Williams had to weigh a multi-million dollar contract for a guy whose health at the time was questionable vs. letting him go in
free agency.  In letting Mags go, the Sox signed Jermaine Dye who was the MVP of the 2005 world series.  He has a ring.  Ordóñez does not.

The most controversial trade Kenny Williams has made came after the world series and was, at the time, hailed for it's genius.  With Frank Thomas cutting his ties to the Sox, a DH was needed.  Going out and acquiring Jim Thome for  Aaron Rowand  seemed brilliant at the time, and really, still does.  As beloved as Rowand was in Chicago, the idea of a lineup with Thome, Konerko and Dye seemed better at the time.  And if the Sox had not traded prospect Chris Young for Javy Vazquez, Young would
be in center for the Sox and we most likely would not be having this conversation. 

But this year, with everybody struggling, there are some that want to relive the past, thinking only ifs and buts.  If you think like that, then you would not be enjoying any of the 2005 World Series Champion merchandise that you proudly wear today.

Lightning Round

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments

  • 8/20/2007 1:53 PM Jeeves wrote:
    Don't forget, the Sox saved a lot of money by trading Lee (and Mags) which allowed them to add the likes of El Duque and Tadahito. I love when people say the Sox would be amazing with Lee, Mags, and Rowand all patroling the outfield at the Cell, while ignoring the fact that Lee and Mags alone would cost $27 mil next year.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.